NEON ICHIBAN
magnifying glass
discover
Discover
Hubs

Community

Review Policy

Effective Date: May 4, 2026

Incentivized reviews

Some reviews on Neon Ichiban are incentivized — the reviewer received digital store credit for posting the review. Incentivized reviews are always marked with a visible label. The badge has two states so the disclosure is honest about whether the credit has actually shipped:

  • Incentivized review (light green) — the credit has been issued. The exact dollar amount is printed inside the badge.
  • Pending review (neutral) — the review is still inside the 24-hour community window and has not earned. It will only earn the incentive if it holds a positive net vote score after the window closes.

A short notice also appears at the top of every review list so readers are primed before they scroll. Screen readers announce the full disclosure via aria-label.

Rewards are never conditional on positive reviews

We never gate payment on a minimum star rating, on positive sentiment, or on recommending the product. A reviewer earns credit for submitting a qualifying review — not for saying anything in particular. The rating field on every review is optional; a one-star review earns exactly the same credit as a five-star review.

Eligibility window — 24 hours of community validation

Each new review enters a 24-hour eligibility window during which the reward sweep does not credit. The window exists to let the community surface low-effort or filler reviews via the downvote action before any credit is issued.

A review only earns the incentive when both of these are true at the end of the window:

  1. The review has not been hidden or removed by moderation.
  2. The review's net vote score (upvotes minus downvotes) is greater than zero.

Reviews that finish the window with a non-positive net score do not earn. They remain visible and continue to count toward platform metrics, but no credit is issued.

Downvote action

Any signed-in member can downvote a review. Downvotes are tallied separately from upvotes and combined into a single net score indicator that is shown next to each review. A net score in red signals a review that is currently below the reward threshold.

We will not act on downvote outcomes in any way other than the eligibility gate above. We do not retroactively claw back rewards from reviews that earned and were later downvoted.

Edit-reset for downvoted reviews

If a review's net score falls below zero, the author may edit the review to clear all existing votes. Editing in this state is treated as a do-over:

  • All upvotes and downvotes on the review are removed.
  • The net score returns to zero.
  • The 24-hour eligibility window restarts from the moment of the edit.

This applies only when the net score is below zero at the moment of the edit, and only if the review has not already earned the incentive. Once the campaign engine has paid out, later edits cannot trigger another reward sweep.

How the reward works

Credit may be earned per review, on a milestone basis, or through other structures as published on the Program Page. The current reward structure — including credit amounts, milestones, and per-user caps — is always available at neonichiban.com/hubs/community/review-policy. Regardless of the structure in effect, the reward is never conditional on what you said or how many stars you gave.

The per-review disclosure badge appears on any review where credit has been earned or attributed — consistent with 16 CFR 255 requiring disclosure on every incentivized endorsement, not only on the one that tipped the reviewer over a milestone threshold.

How disclosure works

  • Every incentivized review shows a two-state badge. The light-green "Incentivized review" pill appears once credit has been issued. The neutral "Pending review" pill appears while the review is still inside the 24-hour window or sitting at a non-positive net score.
  • Tapping or hovering the badge opens a short explainer; on mobile that explainer is inlined beneath the badge so the disclosure is never hidden behind an interaction.
  • The review list includes a one-line notice at the top so readers are primed before scrolling.
  • Assistive-technology users get the full disclosure announced via aria-label.
  • This page is linked from every badge and every list notice.

FTC compliance

This policy is aligned with the FTC Endorsement Guides (16 CFR Part 255) and the 2023 FTC Rule on Fake and Deceptive Reviews. If you spot a review you believe is misleading, or have questions about how rewards work, contact support@neonichiban.com.

Version history

  • 2.0 — May 4, 2026. Added the 24-hour eligibility window, the community downvote action, the edit-reset path for negative-score reviews, and the two-state disclosure badge. Reviews now only earn when their net score is positive at the end of the window.
  • 1.0 — April 28, 2026. Initial publication. Per-review FTC disclosure badge with sentiment-neutral reward language.
← Back to Neon Ichiban
Home
discover
Discover
Hubs
Cart
magnifying glass
Search
more options
More
NEON ICHIBAN

Browse

  • New Releases
  • Publishers
  • Series
  • Creators
  • Marketplace
  • Pre-Orders
  • Search

Publishers

  • DC Comics
  • Marvel Comics
  • Kodansha
  • DSTLRY
  • IDW Publishing
  • Dynamite Entertainment
  • Rebellion
All HubsPre-Order HubCreator PortalCommunity
AboutFAQTermsPrivacySupport

2026 Neon Ichiban. All rights reserved.

NEON ICHIBAN

Your digital comics platform. Discover, collect, and read comics from top publishers.

FacebookInstagramX (Twitter)LinkedInBlueSkyReddit

Browse

  • New Releases
  • Publishers
  • Series
  • Creators
  • Marketplace
  • Pre-Orders
  • Search

Publishers

  • DC Comics
  • Marvel Comics
  • Kodansha
  • DSTLRY
  • IDW Publishing
  • Dynamite Entertainment
  • Rebellion

Hubs

  • All Hubs
  • Pre-Order Hub
  • Creator Portal
  • Community

Company

  • About
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

Support

  • Help Center
  • Contact Support
  • Redeem Code
  • My Collection
  • My Profile
Terms and ConditionsPrivacy PolicyAboutFAQ

© 2026 DSTLRY Media, Inc.

NEON ICHIBAN